While at Goo Lagoon, SpongeBob accidentally rips his pants while trying to impress Sandy, causing everyone to laugh hysterically. Feeling embarrassed, SpongeBob sadly leaves, but a fish compliments him for the good laugh, so he uses this to his advantage. SpongeBob tries to revive his joke multiple times, but it soon becomes old and drives all the beachgoers away, including Sandy. Later, he meets the three “biggest losers on the beach”, and they ask SpongeBob what happened to him. SpongeBob tells his story and apologizes through a song, and wins back Sandy.